search

register
You are not logged in.

Log in »

Subscribe to weekly newsletter »

»

»

»

(Great Movie) »

(Review) »

on sale now

Movie Answer Man

BY ROGER EBERT FILM CRITIC / August 16, 2007

Printer-friendly »
E-mail this to a friend »

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Q. I have a "Godfather" question that NO ONE can answer. In "The Godfather," just before Michael leaves to kill Sollozzo and police Capt. McCluskey, the family is in the Corleone home, trying to determine where Michael will have this meeting. There are six people in the room: Michael, Sonny, Tom, Clemenza, Tessio and an unidentified person wearing a brown suit. He has only seven seconds of screen time and no dialogue.

Who is he? Only the top "family" members would be there as they discuss killing a police captain. Why would anyone outside of the elite group be there?

Phil Giordano, Plainfield , N.J.

A. I am reminded of the great movie line, "And there was another man -- a third man." You list all the possible identities for the sixth man, and explain why it couldn't be any of them. I asked Tim Dirks, author-manager of filmsite.org, which supplies countless invaluable plot details, and he replies: "It looks like Phil Giordano is searching for some 'logical' answer. And he has already dismissed guesses that may be correct. I don't think there's going to be a definitive answer to his question, because of the way he has made assumptions about who the person must be."




AddThis Social Bookmark Button
copyright 2009, rogerebert.com
privacy policyterms of usesubmission guidelines